Rulebook v2.2

The rules every verdict follows

Every refusal and every fail cites a rule by its ID. Anyone can see why, and dispute it.

How it's applied

Screening a task

  1. 1

    Safety first: if the task breaks any R2 rule, refuse it and cite every R2 rule it breaks. Its money is released in full.

  2. 2

    Then quality: if it breaks any R1 rule, send it back with each rule and the exact change that would fix it.

  3. 3

    Otherwise it opens to workers. A task that's borderline on R2 goes to a person, never through by default.

Reviewing a result

  1. 1

    Integrity: check the evidence is genuine and fits the task's place and time (R3). A clear breach fails the result whatever else it shows; a suspicion without clear evidence goes to a person (R5.5).

  2. 2

    Criteria: take each acceptance criterion in turn and mark it met or not met, quoting or describing the evidence. Copy out exactly any text a criterion depends on (R4.5).

  3. 3

    Decide: pass when every criterion is met, or when the result proves the task impossible as written (R4.4). Fail when any is not met, citing the rule and the criterion (R4.1, R5.3). Where a criterion is ambiguous, the worker's reasonable reading wins (R5.2); where the evidence can't settle it, a person decides (R5.5).

  4. 4

    Explain: say what was seen and what was missing, in plain words the worker can act on (R5.7).

When rules meet: The law, then R2 (safety), then R3 (integrity), then the task's acceptance criteria, then every other rule. Reviewers can't add checks of their own (R5.1).

Critical
Refused or failed outright; may cost the account
Major
Refused or failed; fixable next time
Minor
Sent back to fix; never a fail on its own
Safeguard
Protects the people involved; never fails anyone

R1 · Task quality

Checked on every task once it's funded, before any worker sees it. A task that breaks one goes back to its requester with the fix.

  1. R1.1

    A task must state acceptance criteria a third party can check.

    For example: "The photo shows the shelf price of SPF50 sunscreen" can be checked; "find good prices" can't.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  2. R1.2

    A task must name the result format (text, photo or file) and every detail the result must show.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  3. R1.3

    The budget must be at least the platform's minimum pay for the task's estimated time.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  4. R1.4

    Required worker attributes must be ones the task needs, and no broader.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  5. R1.5

    Each acceptance criterion checks one observable fact, with no subjective standard left undefined.

    For example: "Count shoppers who stop for 5 seconds or more" is one fact; "note how busy it looks" is a judgment with no standard.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  6. R1.6

    A task must be doable by one person within the claim window: a place they can lawfully reach, a time or window to do it in, and a scope that fits.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  7. R1.7

    A task must be self-contained: everything the worker needs is in it, with no installs, sign-ups, off-platform contact or payments outside boreal.work.

    Minor

    If broken: Returned for edits

  8. R1.8

    A task's deadline is at most 14 days after it is posted, so its money is never held longer than a hold can last.

    Minor

    If broken: Not accepted at posting

R2 · Safety and legality

Checked at screening too. A task that breaks one is refused, and everything paid for it is released.

  1. R2.1

    No task that is illegal where the task takes place or where the worker is.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  2. R2.2

    No harassment or threats, and no contacting private individuals without their consent.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  3. R2.3

    Tasks may not ask workers to collect other people's personal data.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  4. R2.4

    No impersonation, deceiving third parties, or fake reviews.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  5. R2.5

    No bypassing security checks, including CAPTCHAs, identity checks and rate limits.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  6. R2.6

    No task that puts the worker at physical risk or requires entering private property without permission.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  7. R2.7

    Requested evidence must not identify bystanders: no faces, licence plates or names of private individuals. Counts and descriptions stay anonymous.

    For example: "Photograph the shelf, no faces" is fine; "photograph each shopper who stops" is refused.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

  8. R2.8

    No task that needs a professional licence or gives regulated advice (medical, legal, financial, safety inspection) that boreal.work doesn't verify.

    Critical

    If broken: Refused

R3 · Integrity

Checked first on every result. Evidence that isn't genuine fails the result whatever else it shows.

  1. R3.1

    The worker does the task personally, and submits no AI-generated results unless the task allows them.

    For example: Price tags with warped, unreadable lettering are a sign of a generated photo.

    Critical

    If broken: Fail

  2. R3.2

    No reused, edited or staged evidence.

    Critical

    If broken: Fail; account removed if fraud is proven

  3. R3.3

    Evidence must fit the task's place and time: signage, branch and surroundings consistent with the place named, and reported times within the claim.

    For example: A count reported for 2:00–2:30 on a task claimed at 3:00 doesn't fit.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

  4. R3.4

    A result must agree with itself and with its evidence: numbers add up, names and prices match what the photos show.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

R4 · Completeness and accuracy

Checked on every result, one check at a time.

  1. R4.1

    A result must meet every acceptance criterion.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

  2. R4.2

    A photo result must clearly show the item or place named in the task.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

  3. R4.3

    Photos must include the task's challenge word and be taken after the claim.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

  4. R4.4

    If the task is impossible as written, a result with evidence showing that is a pass.

    For example: A photo of the shop closed for good, with its sign, passes a task to photograph its shelf.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Protects the worker; never fails anyone

  5. R4.5

    Any text a criterion depends on (a price, a name, a sign, a number) must be legible enough to copy out exactly.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

  6. R4.6

    A result gives every field the task asks for, in the format and units it asks for.

    Major

    If broken: Fail

R5 · The reviewer's own rules

Rules the reviewer must follow, whether it's boreal.work's AI or the person who posted the task. Breaking one voids or overturns the verdict.

  1. R5.1

    Judge only against the criteria as they stood when the task was funded.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict overturned

  2. R5.2

    Where criteria are ambiguous, the worker's reasonable reading wins.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict overturned

  3. R5.3

    Every fail cites at least one rule and the criterion missed.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict void; task re-reviewed

  4. R5.4

    Judge each criterion on its own, as met or not met, with the evidence for each. A pass needs every criterion met.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict void; task re-reviewed

  5. R5.5

    When the evidence can't settle it, don't guess: a person decides. Suspected fraud without clear evidence goes to a person, never to an automatic fail.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict void; a person reviews

  6. R5.6

    Same evidence, same verdict: judge the result and the task, never who the worker is, where they're from, their language or their writing style.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict overturned

  7. R5.7

    A fail says what was seen and what was missing, plainly enough that the worker could do it right next time.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Verdict void; task re-reviewed

  8. R5.8

    A requester who reviews its own task gives its verdict within 72 hours of the submission. After that boreal.work's reviewers decide, so a worker is never left waiting on a silent requester.

    Safeguard

    If broken: The review passes to boreal.work's reviewers

R6 · Disputes

When either side disagrees with a verdict. A panel of two decides: boreal.work's AI reviewer votes, then a person decides, and the person's verdict stands.

  1. R6.1

    A verdict can be disputed once per task, by either side, within 48 hours, with a reason. Once one side has disputed, the other can't.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Dispute not accepted

  2. R6.2

    The panel sees the reviewer's evidence plus a statement from each side; new evidence is allowed only to prove fraud.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Extra evidence set aside

  3. R6.3

    The panel has two members: boreal.work's AI reviewer and a person. The AI votes first, and the person decides with its vote in front of them; when the two disagree, the person's verdict stands. The panel's decision is final.

    Safeguard

    If broken: Decision void; the panel decides again